0

Who is the GENI curator for Pinkas Garfinkel and Marya Garfinkel?

Richard

January 04, 2017 09:01

None

Follow

 We have a problem with the entry of Pinkas Garfinkel.

It states that  Pinkas Garfinkel is managed by Lynette Matulovich.

When I wrote to Lynette Matulovich she answered "to tell you the truth I don't know how my name became attached to this profile.  Regards Lynette". 

We have a problem with Marya Garfinkel

It states that I (Richard Hainebach) added this entry on 2 Feb 2009, which I certainly don't remember doing. It also states

that Richard was added as a manager of Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf). May 8, 2015 at 12:53 PM.This seems a contradiction to the earlier information.

It also mentions that Lynette Matulovich, who is a pro member updated the following records

1. Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf)'s profile was updated by Lynette Matulovich. last name May 8, 2015 at 1:00 PM
2. Sophie Glass(Garfinkel) (?????)'s parents were changed to Pinkas Glass(Garfinkel) and Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf) by Lynette Matulovich. May 8, 2015 at 12:53 PM
3. ?????? ????? (Pillersdorf) was merged into Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf) by Lynette Matulovich. May 8, 2015 at 12:53 PM
4. Pinkas Glass(Garfinkel) and Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf)'s marriage was updated by Lynette Matulovich. marriage May 8, 2015 at 10:54 AM
5. Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf) was added as Pinkas Glass(Garfinkel)'s wife by Lynette Matulovich. May 8, 2015 at 10:54 AM

This is bizarre.

 Can you please explain the above?

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 comment

• 0
  
  Jeff, Geni Curator January 04, 2017 14:30

  It looks like a merge was completed on a duplicate tree of Sabrina Ursula Glass, and then through Peter Glass where there were 3 duplicates (one of which was yours).  This led to merging other duplicates of his parents, Sophie Glass (Garfinkel) and Edwin, and then to Marya Garfinkel (Pillersdorf).  You didn't have the Marya profile - Sophie's mother was a conflict, where one tree had "Marya Glass(Garfinkel) (Pillersdorf)" and your branch had "?????? ????? (Pillersdorf)".  Marya had an incorrect last name of "Glass(Garfinkel)" so she then fixed it to Garfinkel.  It does appear that Lynette created Pinkas and Marya prior to the merge.

  When profiles are merged, the added by lists the person that first added the profile, but that same ruleset doesn't apply to selecting the "primary" profile (profile 1 gets merged into profile 2 and profile 1 remains as a sum).  You see your name added as a manager because your profile was profile 2 and it got merged into profile 1, thus added as a manager to profile 1.  You're listed as adding it because profile 2 was older when the two were merged.

  I don't see any problems with it, but if there is an error, I'd be happy to help.