0

Need someone to unmerge lines

https://www.geni.com/people/Dau-Of-Henry-P-Beardsley-Sarah-Cole/6000000094948090884#/tab/discussion

Sarah who married my 3rd great grandfather is daughter of Henry P. There is another Sarah, daughter of Ethan, but they are not the same person. 

https://www.geni.com/people/Samuel-Cole/6000000081646885664?through=6000000094948090884

There is no basis for Raymond as a middle name. Currently these are the Samuel Cole's I have found: 

Cole, Samuel *Livingston NJ 1838
Mar 1838 - New Jersey 1905 - Scranton Ward 2, Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania, USA

Cole, Samuel B NJ 1834
1834 - New Jersey, USA Pennsylvania, USA

Cole, Samuel D. NJ 1830
Abt 1830 - New Jersey 23 July 1900 - Phillipsburg, Warren County, New Jersey

Cole, Samuel L Stone PN 1838
22 Jan 1838 - Pennsylvania 20 Mar 1915 - Blakely, Lackawanna, Pennsylvania, USA

Cole, Samuel S NJ 1833
abt 1833 - New Jersey d.- Lackawanna, Pennysvania

This last man, Samuel S. lived 20 minutes from my Samuel Cole, who at the time resided with my 2nd great Uncle Harry B. Cole. None of these Samuels are the same person. I'm not sure who Samuel Raymond Cole is. This needs more documentation, but I'm not at all convinced they should have been merged unless you too have strong DNA matches to the children of Ann Livingston and John/James Cole through the Hopper line. I believe "Samuel L" and my Samuel father of Percy Livingston (there are two of these guys too), might be the same, but didn't have enough evidence so far. 

2 comments

Please sign in to leave a comment.